THE INCIDENT – A FLIP? YOU BE THE JUDGE…
In February 2023, Group 1-winning trainer Desleigh Forster faced serious scrutiny after she used a prohibited stock whip on a horse named Private Banker at the Eagle Farm racetrack swimming pool.
The incident was not merely a technical breach—it revealed the cruel normalisation of whip use outside racing arenas.
But witnesses say the horse was struck “numerous times”, buckled forward into the pool’s base, then reared and kicked—clearly fearful after repeated whip use.
Although Forster insisted she didn’t intend cruelty, the use of a stock whip had been illegal since 2009.
The governing body’s response was swift: she was initially banned for six months and fined—though the cruelty charge was later overturned on appeal.
Still, her use of a whip on a fearful horse broke the rules—and trust.
WHY THIS INCIDENT MATTERS
1. It happened in a non-competitive setting: Outside a race or training round, yet still the whip emerged.
2. Fear, not instruction, motivated the horse’s response—bucking, rearing, even falling.
3. A top trainer claimed ignorance of the rules and minimized the whip as a harmless tool to “make noise”—highlighting how deeply ingrained whip use remains, even among elites.
Forster’s appeal cleared her on technical cruelty charges, yet she still faced fines for whip possession and use.
The appeal board accepted that she loved horses—but that doesn’t change the facts: she struck one with a prohibited whip, terrified him, and broke the rules.
WHIPS AREN’T JUST TOOLS – THEY ARE WEAPONS OF CONTROL
Whether to send a horse into water, across a jump, or down the final stretch, the whip remains a go-to solution for forcing compliance.
But compliance under fear is not training. It is control. It often backfires, eliciting stress, confusion, and injury—not learning or partnership.
WHAT WE DEMAND
Zero tolerance: Whips must be removed from all equestrian disciplines, not just racing.
Clear rules and consistent enforcement: Bans aren’t worth much if they go unenforced.
Compassionate training: Horses deserve methods grounded in trust, not terror.
SUPPORT REAL CHANGE
Desleigh Forster’s case is a wake-up call. Even champions can slip into cruelty when whips are both legal and socially accepted. But we can demand better.
When you donate to Meet Our Horse Meat, you fund:
Investigations that expose hidden abuses
Campaigns pushing for total whip bans in all horse sports
Education to dismantle cruel training traditions
If you believe compliance shouldn’t cost a horse his dignity—or his safety—help us end the whip.
Because a whip is forceful. Control doesn’t equal care.
#MOHM THREATENED?
We’ve been threatened by those in the horse racing industry and those who benefit from horse slaughter more times than we can count.
But we are not going away.
We are going to persist until horse slaughter no longer exists for any purpose within Australia -- and until the horse racing industry makes drastic changes.
We are going to continue our hands-on work to offer lifelong sanctuary to as many horses as possible. We generally have 20 at just one of our locations - at any given time.
We have the acreage to take on more horses as financial support allows.
MP PETA MURPHY’S LEGACY & THE AMA’S WARNING
YOU WIN SOME - YOU LOSE MOREWhen Peta Murphy chaired the parliamentary inquiry into gambling, she called it what it is: a public health crisis. The late MP warned that gambling was destroying lives at a scale few Australians truly understand. Her report titled, 'You...
BY THE NUMBERS – AUSTRALIA’S GAMBLING SHAME
THE STAGGERING STATISTICSThe gambling industry loves to tell Australians it’s all just harmless fun. But the statistics paint a picture of devastation that can’t be ignored.Australians lose about AUD 31.5 billion per year to legal gambling. That amount is more than...
Join us on social media and become a keyboard warrior.
